Socialist Alternative

Democrats Cave On Shutdown: Working People Need A New Party

Published on

At this point it’s difficult to fully capture in words how thoroughly bankrupt and pathetic the Democrats are. Even former senior Obama advisor and Pod Save America co-host, Dan Pfeiffer, summed up their capitulation on the government shutdown with: “Well, no one can snatch defeat from the jaws of victory like the Democrats.”

The Democrats won a wave of electoral upsets across the country just two weeks ago, which even Trump blamed on the shutdown and the Democrats’ refusal to let healthcare funding expire. Less than a week later, they turned around to strike a deal with Trump and Senate Republicans, ending the longest government shutdown in US history in exchange for…nothing.

A poll from last week found that 55% of people believe Trump and Republicans got more of what they wanted from ending the shutdown. Only 6% said Democrats came out on top, and 24% said neither party did.

The Democrats did not save the healthcare subsidies they promised to save. They asked federal workers to sacrifice their paychecks for well over a month just to turn around and win nothing out of it. For workers making $825 a week, the average take-home pay of an AFGE member (the largest federal workers’ union), missing a paycheck was the difference between making rent or not, full meals or partial meals, medication or no medication. For the nearly 40 million people who rely on food stamps, losing two weeks of those benefits meant families going to food banks or skipping meals. Meanwhile, the median net worth of a US senator from either party is over $1 million.

The ending of Affordable Care Act subsidies will mean 20 million people will have their healthcare premiums more than double starting next year, including many people in states controlled by Republicans. That means those people will have to start paying an average of nearly $2,000 a year just for their healthcare premiums, before all the other costs of healthcare like co-pays and medications. This can add to growing anger among even Trump supporters, already sparked by continued inflation and the rising cost of groceries. Just last week, Trump was forced to backtrack on a number of food-related tariffs. 

In the days after the shutdown began, we wrote: “[The Democrats] absolutely should not cave, but they can’t win and won’t win this fight for us. Restoring healthcare tax credits, restoring and increasing Medicaid funding, stopping the mass deportations, Trump’s attacks on trans people—defeating Trump’s agenda in general—will not be won by the Democratic Party. This can only be accomplished through mass, organized, working-class action.”

Where Were The Unions?

But the organized working class, who were pointed nowhere by union leaders who refused to put up a fight, was missing in action. Unlike the shutdown in 2019, the labor movement played no role in ending this shutdown on workers’ terms. In fact, the leadership of AFGE did the opposite at the end of last month, when they gave up and called for Democrats to abandon healthcare funding and reopen the government. It is understandable that many federal workers desperately needed their paychecks, and it is true that the Democrats’ war-of-attrition approach to the shutdown was not working. But that’s exactly why the labor movement needed to step in early with an escalatory approach. Without this, AFGE leadership ended up effectively pitting their members against other working people who rely on healthcare subsidies. It’s even worse to consider that many AFGE members rely on the same benefits. Ultimately, many federal workers are frustrated that they sacrificed for nothing.

In 2019, Sara Nelson, president of the Association of Flight Attendants, called on flight attendants to go to the offices of their congresspeople and stay until the shutdown was ended. That was what forced Trump to end the 2018-2019 shutdown without even winning funding for his border wall. This year would have required an even bigger fight, given how Trump’s more reactionary, more authoritarian regime is willing to go further than before to crush workers and their organizations of struggle.

It would have required a call led by the federal worker unions on the entire labor movement for mass demonstrations outside of airports and federal buildings, combined with mass meetings to organize workplace action and school walkouts, building ultimately towards larger-scale workplace action, including strikes against the shutdown and Trump’s agenda as a whole. This would have had the potential to force Republicans to abandon cuts to ACA subsidies and reopen the government on workers’ terms. Union leaders refuse to organize this type of struggle for a fight against Trump that is very much not over yet, relying solely instead on the inherently unreliable courts. That means rank-and-file union members will need to get organized to force their union leaders to take up the necessary actions like political strikes, while bringing workers across every industry into the fight with them.

Neither Party Works For Us

In the most recent YouGov survey where people were asked to choose who they blamed most for the shutdown, 32% blamed Democrats, 35% Republicans, and 28% both equally. This marked a 4% increase in blaming both sides equally compared to an earlier survey. Workers and young people in the US are increasingly disillusioned and disgusted with both parties, seeing nothing on offer from the establishment that will meaningfully improve their lives.

Democratic socialist Zohran Mamdani so decisively won the recent mayor’s race in NYC because he ran on a platform of serious demands to make the city more affordable and a promise to go to the mat fighting for it—in complete contrast to everything the Democratic Party, and the Republican Party, represent. Winning Zohran’s demands will take a relentless class-struggle approach, that looks nothing like what the Democrats or Republicans have ever done, to defeat the incredibly powerful billionaires who run New York City. That’s why we call on Zohran to break with the Democratic Party completely and build an independent alternative based on the hunger for real, progressive change reflected by the over 100,000 people who volunteered for his campaign.

If there was a genuinely working-class alternative to the establishment parties on offer, it’s clear that millions of people in this country would support it. We need a workers’ party that can serve as a place to organize a mass fightback against Trump and the billionaires of both parties who will never stop trying to make our lives harder and more miserable in order to line their pockets. 

We need a party with a socialist program that rejects workers being pitted against one another and goes on the offensive to fight for the things we all desperately need—like not merely trying to save the meager healthcare subsidies that exist, but building a massive struggle for free, universal healthcare, paid for by taxing the rich. This is not a pipe dream: just look at Your Party in Britain and the enormous potential to construct a serious, independent, left alternative to the existing political parties. We can win a world where no families go hungry while millionaire politicians play debate club with our lives, but we’ll have to get organized and fight for it in our workplaces, our unions, our schools, and in the streets.

Latest articles

MORE LIKE THIS

What Should The Democratic Socialists Do Now?

Eight DSA members will be in the new Congress and their mandate is unmistakable. Tens of millions of people did not vote for a...

Trump & Republicans Routed: What Now To Defeat Their Whole Agenda

The wave became a tsunami: the Republicans, with Trump at their head, were absolutely trounced in the midterm elections. Tens of millions of people...

Federal Agents Raid Ilhan Omar’s Home—Fight Back Against Political Repression & Attacks On Immigrants!

On the morning of October 12, federal agents raided a house in one of Washington DC’s northeast neighborhoods. They were collecting evidence. Was it...

Talarico Could Break The Republican Grip On Texas—But Workers Need A Party Of Our Own

With the midterms less than a week away, Trump's approval rating is at a record low. The Trump regime has attempted to overcome its...